Couple of definitions I think are useful to understand:
A vocation, Latin for "calling", is a term for an occupation to which a person is specially drawn or for which they are suited, trained or qualified. Though now often used in secular contexts, the meanings of the term originated in Christianity. (from Wiki)
Job-a specific piece of work, as in one's trade, or done by agreement for pay anything one has to do; task; chore; duty the thing or material being worked on
Profession-a calling requiring specialized knowledge and often long and intensive academic preparation
How do I know that I love my profession? I can honestly say that, without a doubt, I would work in women's health for free. Am I nuts or what?
Back when I was a fledgling doula and working on childbirth education, I would offer my services for free or donation just to get experience. What I found is that by doin' it just to do it, I formed relationships and found so much joy in the "work."
I've been thinking a lot about whether or not registered nurse childbirth educators are in general a good idea--especially when they are in a hospital setting. A lot of my thinking has stemmed from recent events involving my own search for certification and the different personalities I have encountered over the last 10 years on this vocational journey of mine.
It seems that forming relationships--or even just rapport--with your students enhances their ability to learn. That's a nursing 101 concept. I wonder if the hospital setting and agenda, coupled with other barriers to learning found in a hospital environment like lecture halls, cold room, florescent lighting, and intimidating medical garb and mumbo-jumbo, all negatively impact how childbirth and other CBE classes are taught.
A CBE instructor recently told me that pregnant women and their support persons expect a high tech, academic setting for their CBE classes, which explains the newfangled use of powerpoint and other media during class. I agree, as Americans we expect a lot for our money, but I am wondering how all this fits with a holistic and more of a midwifery model of education (if that exists)?
As an aside, the average cost of childbirth classes in this country is $110. Not a lot of money for a 6 week series, but a good chunk for an all day class. Hm.
I guess all this is just rumbling around in my head, coupled with the new knowledge I have made about my vocation: I have become an integral part of the highly medicalized childbirth practices found in hospitals today. In a real sense, I am a part of the problem. Yep.
Isn't that weird--for someone who has so believed in natural childbirth and all its accoutrements, that I would be the one following orders by physically tying women down in the bed with various tubes and wires, introducing synthetic oxytocin into their veins, pumping them with narcotics when they have pain, constantly watching what their bodies do on a computer screen, all so I could control their labors? It would be laughable if not so shocking.
And I'm not going to lie: I love technology--especially the technology of nursing. I love the gadgets, the machines, the hospital itself. I'm just not sure how far that love extends? Is it enough to keep me at the bedside of a healthy laboring mom, when that mom shouldn't be in bed at all?
For now, yes. I'm not ready to jump ship. I just don't have a lifeboat waiting around, yet.
But back to teaching in a hospital environment, I don't know if I can do it. I want to teach in women's homes, where they feel comfortable. I want to forgo PowerPoint's and academia, and focus instead on relationship, women helping women, partners not "coaching" but "supporting" and "loving" and "touching."
But then again, maybe I can change something if I do teach at the hospital? (Yeah, and we've see how well that has gone at the hospital when I am "laboring" someone! *sigh*)
See, I have all these ideals and none of them meet in the middle. I am pulled in opposite directions by these paths I have chosen. Which makes me again consider nurse midwifery--maybe the best way to blend it all?? Yes, I am back at that starting point.
What I am doing now as a labor and delivery nurse is part job and part vocation--and somewhat uncomfortable. But a blessing, nonetheless. Oh, and I do get paid for this craziness.
PS The move is going well! ;)
7.30.2009
Doing it all for the money?
Posted by Prisca: at 8:02 AM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
You get paid for the craziness -- that's the most important part right now. You're getting paid to do something you like, love, and/or are called to do. Your family needs that. Don't jump ship -- just work on building another boat while you're still safely on the first ship.
One problem with hospital-based CBE classes, is that all too often, they're "how to be a good patient and do what we say" classes. The one I attended my first pregnancy was like that; and I've heard that refrain from numerous others. My Bradley teacher said that a hospital-based birth educator was "called on the carpet" because she gave out the informed consent forms for C-sections & epidurals during class. Too many women started refusing these interventions, and the management wasn't happy about that. But the women were truly being informed and declined said intervention -- that's supposedly what "informed consent *and refusal*" is all about. But it wasn't -- in that hospital, anyway.
You may want to start teaching in your hospital (and quit if it's not a good fit), because you'll have an instant market. But you may want to start teaching in people's homes, since that's what you feel drawn to. One thing to watch out for is that your hospital might not like that free-lancing -- perhaps they'd have some liability issues if one of their RNs "gave medical advice" even in private CBE.
Certainly *some* people expect high-tech academics, but many do not. You could also combine technology with touch (as you would during birth) and have the best of both worlds -- you could have a PP presentation instead of low-tech drawing on a chalkboard, with ample time built in to connecting with the students on a personal level.
-Kathy
good points kathy--and even more to think about. as usual you have left a great comment. thanks!
I'm struggling with this too... currently stalling my CAPPA Lactation Educator home study that I'm taking. Why oh why do I need to do that, when I could just be an IBCLC? Then I think about my doula practice - why be a doula when I could just work in L and D?
I also took the NRP course (being an RN makes it open) so I could possibly be a second attendant at home births once they get going in my community. I'm patiently awaiting a midwife to swoop me up and take me on her journey until midwifery is something I can relocate my family and do...
It's all a huge whirlwind right now, deciding what kind of nursing I want to do, what kind of birthing-related career I want, all in the midst of dealing with a one year old, a busy husband, a 9 year old pre-teen girl...dogs...finances...renovations...family stress...
Don't know where to go, all I know is I have the option of a masters degree, a masters in midwifery, the IBCLC, or just putzing around my own community and filling voids where they need to be filled.
All I know is that I wouldn't fit in on the L and D unit. I'm a craptastic ward nurse because I really love nursing and caring and nurturing my clients and it always seems to get in the way of the politics. I'd love to teach but I have no seniority.
So I settled for working for a blood donation agency, which is less politics but not in an area of interest. And working at a seniors care home doing minor staff teaching and training.
Sigh. I feel your pain... wanting to be at birth but not having an avenue at the moment.
Post a Comment